When is Divorce Mediation Not Recommended

When is Divorce Mediation not Recommended?

When is Divorce Mediation Not Recommended? If the divorce is full of really strong emotions that stop people from talking things out well, it might not be a good idea.

Also, if someone has problems with drugs or alcohol, it can make it hard for them to make good decisions or work together with others. In cases like these, dealing with the substance issues first might be needed.

When Might Divorce Mediation not be the Best Choice?

Divorce is tough, no doubt about it. And when you’re looking for ways to make it a bit less tough, mediation often comes up as a suggestion. It’s like a bridge between going it alone and battling it out in court. But it’s not a one-size-fits-all solution.

There are times when stepping into mediation is like trying to put out a fire with gasoline. Let’s chat about when mediation might not be the move.

The Big No-Nos for Mediation

1. When There’s Abuse in the Picture

If there’s been physical or emotional abuse in the relationship, mediation can be more than just ineffective; it can be unsafe. Abuse creates an imbalance of power that makes fair negotiation pretty much impossible. The priority here should be safety and protection, not negotiation.

2. Major Imbalance of Power

Even without abuse, if there’s a big power gap between the two people (think one person calling all the shots and the other person just going along with it), mediation might end up being a one-sided affair. It’s all about balance. If one person can easily dominate the conversation, the outcome won’t be fair.

3. Hidden Assets or Income

Honesty is the best policy, especially in mediation. If there’s a sneaking suspicion that one person isn’t being upfront about their finances, it’s a red flag for mediation. Both parties need to be open books to reach a fair agreement.

4. High Conflict Situations

Some couples can’t be in the same room without World War III breaking out. If that’s the case, mediation might add fuel to the fire. Mediation relies on cooperation and communication. If those are off the table, it’s probably not going to work.

5 benefits of divorce mediation

  1. Cost-Effective: Mediation often costs significantly less than traditional litigation. Without the need for multiple court appearances and the associated legal fees, couples can save money.
  2. Faster Resolution: Mediation typically takes less time than going through the courts. Couples can move on more quickly with their lives, reducing prolonged stress and uncertainty.
  3. More Control: Both parties have more say in the outcome. Instead of a judge deciding the terms of the divorce, the couple works together to reach mutually beneficial agreements.
  4. Privacy: Mediation sessions are private, unlike public court proceedings. This privacy can protect individuals and families from the public disclosure of personal details and conflicts.
  5. Improved Communication: Mediation encourages open communication and cooperation, which can be particularly beneficial for maintaining a functional relationship post-divorce, especially when children are involved.

What Are the Alternatives?

So, if mediation is off the table, what’s plan B? Well, it might mean traditional litigation, in which each person gets a lawyer and works it out in court.

There are also collaborative divorces, where each person has a lawyer, but everyone agrees to work together cooperatively. And sometimes, if it’s just about making decisions for the kids, a family court or a child custody evaluator might be the way to go.

Alternative Dispute Resolution Options

When divorce mediation isn’t the right fit, there are several alternative dispute resolution (ADR) options available to manage conflicts, including divorce. Here’s a brief overview of some common alternatives:

  1. Collaborative Divorce
    • What It Is: Both parties hire their attorneys, who are committed to a non-adversarial process. The goal is to reach an agreement without going to court.
    • Best For: Couples seeking a structured yet flexible negotiation with professional support.
  2. Arbitration
    • What It Is: A neutral third party, the arbitrator, makes decisions after hearing arguments and evidence from both sides. It’s more formal than mediation but less so than court.
    • Best For Disputes where parties want a binding decision but prefer to avoid court.
  3. Early Neutral Evaluation
    • What It Is: An expert assesses the case’s merits early on and provides a non-binding evaluation. This helps both parties develop a realistic understanding of their situation.
    • Best For: Couples needing clarity on specific issues to streamline negotiations.
  4. Conciliation
    • What It Is: It is similar to mediation, but the conciliator may provide advice and propose solutions to help reach an agreement.
    • Best For: Couples who need more guidance to resolve their disputes.
  5. Family Group Conferencing
    • What It Is: A meeting involving extended family members to discuss and resolve issues concerning care and protection, often used in child custody situations.
    • Best For: Situations where the well-being of children is a central concern and family dynamics play a significant role.
  6. Parenting Coordination
    • What It Is: A child-focused process in which a mental health professional or legal professional assists high-conflict parents in implementing parenting plans, making decisions, and resolving disputes.
    • Best For: High-conflict situations where children’s needs are paramount.
  7. Restorative Justice Processes
    • What It Is: It focuses on repairing harm and restoring relationships, typically involving dialogue between the affected parties.
    • Best For: Situations where relationships can be mended or closure is needed on emotional issues.

Each of these ADR methods offers distinct advantages and is suited to different types of disputes and personal circumstances. Choosing the right one depends on your specific needs, goals, and the complexity of the issues at hand.

Top 10 questions before deciding if divorce mediation is right for you

  1. Is communication still possible?
    Can you and your spouse communicate without too much conflict?
  2. Are you both willing?
    Do both of you agree to try mediation?
  3. Safety concerns?
    Is there any history of abuse in the relationship?
  4. Can you negotiate fairly?
    Are you both able to discuss and negotiate without one dominating the other?
  5. Ready to disclose finances?
    Are you both willing to openly share financial information?
  6. What about the kids?
    Can you work together to decide what’s best for any children involved?
  7. Looking for a flexible solution?
    Do you prefer a customizable agreement over a court-ordered one?
  8. Cost considerations?
    Are you seeking a less expensive alternative to traditional divorce proceedings?
  9. How quickly do you want to resolve this?
    Are you looking for a potentially faster way to finalize your divorce?
  10. Can you handle a DIY approach?
    Are you comfortable with a process that might require more personal responsibility than a court-driven divorce?

Key Facts on Divorce Mediation Effectiveness

Success Rate of Divorce MediationApproximately 70-80% of mediation cases result in a settlement outside of court.
Average Cost of Mediation vs. LitigationMediation costs on average $6,000 – $7,000 total, whereas litigation can cost $15,000 – $30,000 per person.
Duration of Mediation ProcessMediation costs, on average, $6,000 – $7,000 total, whereas litigation can cost $15,000 – $30,000 per person.
Percentage of Cases Reaching Agreement on All IssuesAbout 90% of mediated divorces reach an agreement on all issues.
Impact of Mediation on ChildrenStudies show that mediation results in better post-divorce outcomes for children, including less conflict and improved communication between parents.
Rate of Compliance with Mediated AgreementsCompliance with mediated agreements is high, with rates often exceeding 80%, compared to 60% for litigated agreements.
Use of Mediation in High-Conflict DivorcesDespite high conflict, over 50% of high-conflict divorces that go through mediation reach a full agreement.
Reconciliation Through MediationWhile not common, approximately 2-3% of couples seeking mediation end up reconciling during the process.

When not to use mediation?

Avoid mediation in cases of abuse, significant power imbalances, non-disclosure of assets, or when high conflict prevents productive communication.

What are the 3 disadvantages of mediation?

It may not resolve power imbalances between parties.
Confidentiality can limit legal protections.
Outcomes depend heavily on both parties’ willingness to cooperate, which may not be feasible in high-conflict situations.

Can mediation lead to reconciliation?

While it’s designed for negotiation and settlement, the cooperative and communicative process of mediation can sometimes help couples find a way to reconcile, though it’s not its primary goal.

Is mediation before or after divorce?

Mediation usually occurs before the divorce is finalized. It is a way to negotiate the terms of the divorce agreement outside of court.

Why do people avoid mediation?

People might avoid mediation because they mistrust the process, fear being overpowered in negotiations, have concerns about confidentiality, or have the belief that their dispute is too complex for mediation.

What are the 3 rules for the mediation?

Confidentiality: Everything said in mediation stays.
Neutrality: The mediator cannot take sides or make decisions for the parties.
Voluntariness: Participation is voluntary, and either party can walk away from mediation at any time.

What is the disadvantage of mediation?

There is no guaranteed outcome. Both parties need to agree on a solution.

Can mediation lead to reconciliation?

Yes, mediation can help mend relationships by fostering communication and understanding.

Is mediation before or after divorce?

Mediation can be used before or after divorce to settle disputes regarding child custody, property division, etc.

In Conclusion

Divorce mediation is a tool, and like any tool, it’s not right for every job. It works best when both people can talk it out, be honest, and want to reach a fair agreement. But when safety, honesty, and balance are issues, it’s time to look for another path. Remember, the goal is to find the best way forward for everyone involved, especially if there are kids in the picture.

Learn how divorce mediation works so that you know before doing anything.

Share this

Take the first step:

Let’s talk about you.

We offer no obligation, free 1hr consultations to people like you. Let’s talk about your situation. Really. 

Stay Connected

Recent Posts

Can You Refuse Mediation in a Divorce

Can You Refuse Mediation in a Divorce?

In Calgary, neither party is forced to participate in or continue with family mediation if they don’t want to. However, separating couples are encouraged to settle their disputes out of court whenever possible. This approach can save time, reduce stress, and often lead to more amicable solutions. What is Mediation in Divorce? Mediation is a

Read More »
How to protect yourself financially in a divorce

How to protect yourself financially in a divorce?

Divorce can be an emotional rollercoaster, but your finances don’t have to suffer. Protecting yourself financially during this challenging time is crucial for securing your future. Whether you’re facing a separation or a full divorce in Calgary, these essential tips will help you navigate the financial complexities and come out stronger on the other side.

Read More »
What Am I Entitled to in a Divorce in Alberta

What Am I Entitled to in a Divorce in Alberta?

When you go through a divorce in Alberta, you are entitled to an equitable division of marital assets and liabilities. This means the assets accrued during the marriage are divided fairly between spouses, though not always equally. It also includes considerations for spousal support, depending on the length of the marriage, each spouse’s income, and

Read More »